The Lexington Candy Shop

The Lexington Candy Shop is the oldest continuously operating luncheonette in Manhattan, where you can indulge in a classic New York egg cream. This delightful drink, which dates back to the 1920s, is a unique blend of cold milk, seltzer, and flavored syrup—despite its misleading name, it contains neither eggs nor cream! The shop itself is a charming time capsule, with its vintage decor untouched since 1948, making it feel like a step back into the past. Whether you're sipping on their famous coffee-flavored egg cream or enjoying a thick milkshake made with a retro Hamilton Beach mixer, you’ll be soaking up a piece of NYC history at this beloved local gem. Don't miss the chance to experience not just the flavors but also the nostalgic ambiance that makes Lexington Candy Shop a must-visit for anyone wanting to connect with the city's rich culinary heritage.

Photo: Karla & James Murray